After 5 years of focusing my attention on the behaviour differences between generations in the workplace, I’ve come to a few conclusions. Let me explain. There’s a long list of reasons why I’ve come to believe in these conclusions – which I don’t have the space to explain here. Instead, I’ll share the highlights (I’d like to say ‘Coles Notes’, but my Millennial and Gen Z readers might roll their eyes and stop reading.).
For the last 10 years, many employers have thrown their arms up in despair and frustration at trying to understand how to work with Millennials. It’s actually not that hard. And, they’re not lazy. They’re not self-entitled either. Millennials are highly creative, and prefer to work as a part of the ‘hive mind’ collective. They want to collaborate. And they need encouragement – in real-time, and often. They are now in their late 20’s through early 40’s.
The employer / employee clash comes when Gen X and Baby boomers are operating with the old paradigm toward work in our profession – commit to the company, show up, work hard, pull your own weight, hit the targets/metrics you’re told to achieve, get your cheque, and as for feedback, well no news is good news now then isn’t it!? Well, actually, no, not any more. If you’re a Gen X (early 40’s thru late 50’s) or Baby Boomer (60-ish thru early 70’s), then you’re likely frustrated with the ‘attitude’ of most ‘young people’ that you hire because of the work ethic you perceive them to have.
And the Millennial employees who find themselves in the midst of companies led like that, run screaming in the opposite direction, in search for a workplace where the will be treated as a collaborative and valued person on the team – from day one. As for the ‘show up’ part – Millennials are social, and community minded – they crave being valued and appreciated. If there’s something in their personal life or circle that trumps your targets and budgets, then they’re likely not showing up for you every day. And they dislike conflict – so if they know they’ll get ‘in trouble’ for taking a day off – they just won’t call in and get the hassle, they just don’t show up and then based on the reaction when they return to work – they either shrug it off or leave altogether. They rarely will work the long hours in a day or week that you might. But they will work as hard, if you meet them on their terms. Paid time off is a great example of helping Millennials feel more committed to the company. Paid time to do a community / volunteer project can be a very sticky benefit to offer.
This cohort (now in their mid 20’s and younger) aren’t as ‘needy’ as millennials may seem. They aren’t as set on being a part of a collaborating, co-creating group. This generation has a bit more independence. They want to know how they are doing, and measure their own progress or success on individually assigned projects or goals – or on their own ‘part’ of a workday team plan.
And, this generation is also highly curious, and extremely protective of their life-work balance. Note that ‘life’ comes first here. They are timid, curious, social and a bit flighty. Easily intimidated. Sensitive to criticism of either themselves or of others around them, if it is not accompanied with coaching for improved results. They aren’t afraid to learn but they insist on feeling they’ve been set up for success. If they don’t, they’ll bolt for the door. Culture therefore, is critical. This generation needs to feel autonomy – a tough challenge for employers running crews, and welcoming ‘entry-level’ workers into a company that’s set up with a hierarchy of levels of authority and control.
The companies that are successful engaging this vibrant, bright and curious generation, are those who have shifted the leadership paradigm around the meaning of ‘hard work’ and ‘life balance’. And if you want to have success building the team you need, then get with this program – Life Work Balance. Ask them what that means to them, and engage in the conversation.
I was recently coaching a husband and wife business owner Millennial team. They were asking for advice on motivation. After proudly describing a bonus system they’d devised for their teams, including how the shared ‘leader board’ displayed employee ‘points’ earned on performance each month – and who was ‘leading/winning’ the contest, I asked them if the program worked. They both laughed and said it was an absolute failure. One of the terms they kept using was ‘here’s the numbers we need to meet’. BINGO. Externally defined, meaningless goals in a bonus system based on achieving numbers that were meaningful to the owners – not to the team. AND, a system designed to publicly shame those who were struggling to meet or compete with the targets. Doomed to fail. The team btw are mostly younger Millennials and Gen Z over 20.
The solution we discussed was Gen Z-based thinking: Stop talking about gross profit or job costing targets up front. Start talking about what is scheduled for any given crew for a week, and let them figure out how to get the work done on time, and to standard. Consider setting in place more of a ‘salary’ than ‘hourly rate’. It’s easier than you might think.
Seriously, as an employer, if you were to turn it around into a Gen Z context – and say ‘I’ll pay you $X.xx per week for the season. Some weeks will be heavier than others depending on the time of year. The attention to detail has to be met. The schedule will be reasonable. If you and your team mates can figure out a way to get the work done at or above standard, in less time, then you get paid time off. ‘ I.e. be super efficient and diligent, show up and dig in, and you can get hot or rainy days off, or half days, or Fridays off , or start later each day – etc.
Individually motivated to get what they want – more time off – and steady paycheque. BINGO.
If you’re struggling with finding the motivation miracle – My suggestion is simple: Look in the mirror. If you see any grey hair, odds are that your company might be running ‘behind the times’.